In this conversation Prof. Wolff and I respond to the opportunity posed by the rise of a new Democratic majority in Congress, especially the left-populist group known as The Bloc. This is a time, not to compromise, but to aspire. Many important ideas are already changing the political landscape, including Medicare for All and expanded Social Security. But the world is filled with great ideas, and ideas yet to be imagined. With each step forward, new opportunities arise and new horizons appear.
It’s a virtuous cycle: new energy generates new ideas, and new ideas generate new energy.
With that in mind, I proposed that Prof. Wolff and I spend our time this week exploring (I hate the word “brainstorming,” but brainstorming) new thoughts and innovations be introduced into public debate. They included:
Sectoral bargaining: where all the workers in a given industry negotiate collectively through their union for a contract that includes all of them, regardless of the company that employs them.
Nationalizing AI—both the data and the infrastructure behind it.
A maximum income, not just a minimum wage.
Fully funded public housing.
A “People’s Fed” that would be democratically organized and managed.
National rent control.
An “institute of new political thinking” to explore new ideas—from around the world, from history, and from the dreams and aspirations of the American public.
We covered many more ideas, and had some especially harsh words for the Fed. As always, please give it a listen and let me know what you think.
The transcript is below.
This work is only possible thanks to continuing reader support. If you find it worthwhile, please help out with a paid subscription through Substack (discounted here) or on Patreon. You can also make a one-time contribution here.
Many thanks—RJE
Transcript (lightly edited)
[intro clip]
Richard Eskow: At breakfast the other day a friend of mine posed a question. We now have some genuinely left, fresh faces in “The Bloc” who haven’t been brainwashed by the Democratic Party—at least not yet. They include self-described socialists and democratic socialists, along with other progressives who don’t seem to mince words about who they are or what they believe. They were elected despite years of being told that such people cannot be win in the United States. They won anyway, including in parts of the country where we’ve been told that absolutely can’t happen. So much for that fake argument.
With that in mind my friend posed a challenge (which I’ll paraphrase): there are excellent and important ideas already out there, such as Medicare for All, expanding Social Security, and cutting this insane military budget. But, he said, if you were asked for some new ideas this nascent left in Washington could propose, what would you suggest? I was just improvising, obviously, but my first thought was to strengthen the labor movement and permit the practice known as “sectoral bargaining.” The idea is practiced in a number of other Western countries, and those countries have not been annihilated by rowdy, insurrectionist workers. It’s a simple idea: everybody who works building auto parts, for example, negotiates collectively with all of their employers. There’s a common rate, a common contract, common benefits, and common terms for all of them. This amplifies the strength of working people and allows us to negotiate on a much closer footing (not nearly an equal footing, but much closer to one) than we have now.
That was one idea. Another, which I’ve been writing about for years, is that we should nationalize AI, both the data and the infrastructure behind it. But I wanted to give the question more thought, because while I’m all for Medicare for All, what we’ve seen over the last few years is the right moving the so-called Overton window of discussion in lunatic directions that people would never have considered and should never consider.
I would like to see this as a time for germinating and discussing new ideas. Let a hundred flowers bloom, if you will. And frankly, I think that’s also something Democrats must do: not just deliver, as you said, but show that at least some people among them are incubating or considering great new ideas.
So what’s your reaction to that?
Richard Wolff: I’d love to do it. I think it’s an exercise whose time has come, on many levels. So I’m up for it. My brain is rushing ahead, trying to think of what’s important for me to contribute. I’m ready to go.
Richard Eskow: Okay. I gave you two, and I’m happy to back them up. I have more, but I’ve laid out the case for sectoral bargaining, and I’ve come on your program, as well as this one, to discuss the case for nationalizing AI. So it’s your turn. Come on.
Richard Wolff: All right, I’ll do some. I’m going to be brief, and then you can go back and talk about them in more depth if you want. I have been struck, here in New York City, by the importance of the issue of rent control in the election of Zohran Mamdani, for example. It is a scandal in this country.
Around the world, it is thought that 25 percent of your income is the maximum your housing should cost you. And there are literally tens of millions of Americans who are now paying more than 25 percent of their income. We need some sort of rent control. We have many, many decades of experience with rent control here in New York City, elsewhere in this country, and around the world to draw upon to make it a national program.
Number two: we have a minimum wage, but as has been discussed in other countries, why don’t we also have a maximum wage? A wage beyond which it is not necessary or appropriate for anyone to go. And there are a lot of ways of doing that.
Number three: we allow rich people to play the states off against each other. The example was the defeat of the proposition in California for a one-time 5 percent tax on billionaires. They spent hundreds of millions of dollars, much more than they would have had to pay in the tax, to defeat it. And a major argument they used was the threat: if you dare do this, we will leave.
Now, the place everybody thought they would go, and the place they often referred to, was Texas. But of course, given the results of the vote, they’ll have to rethink that, and quickly. I would argue that we should not allow this to be a game in which one state undercuts the chances of the vote going the other way in another state.
If it were a national program, putting a one-time or small-percentage tax on wealth over, say, $10 million or $20 million, so that it really applies only to the super-rich, then states couldn’t be played off against one another. The federal government would collect it and then rebate it to the state where the individual who paid it resided, so that state would get the benefit.
We could handle it that way. The next one is probably the most important to me. Here, I’m going to borrow the way it has been formulated in Great Britain and Italy as models, because that underscores that we’re not starting from scratch. These are not ideas we pulled out of the air.
These are ideas that have already been developed elsewhere, and we could draw on them. There should be freedom of choice in the United States that allows Americans to choose whether to buy from, work in, or both, non-hierarchical, non-capitalist enterprises: worker co-ops, to be blunt. Co-ops, such as food co-ops, already touch millions of Americans.
Now, this is a co-op in which workers collectively, as a community, run their enterprise democratically: one worker, one vote. Those exist in the United States. The plan would be to create a sector, maybe 10 percent, maybe 20 percent of our national economy, organized that way, so that people everywhere can see the difference in the product or service they buy from a democratically run enterprise.
Likewise, they could choose between looking for a job in the co-op sector or in the traditional, hierarchical, top-down sector. Now, who’s done this? First, the example from Italy. It’s called the Marcora Law, passed in 1985. It allows an unemployed worker in Italy who can find at least nine others like themselves to go to the government and, instead of getting a weekly stipend (the dole, unemployment compensation), receive their entire year or year and a half of entitlement in a lump sum right away.
That’s on condition that it is used to start a co-op enterprise. This keeps people from sitting there feeling bad about themselves for a year and a half. It creates new businesses left and right, which it has done in Italy, so that even the opposition of the ruling class in Italy has not gotten that law repealed.
It’s on the books as I’m speaking to you. The same law, passed in 1985, has stood the test of time. The second example comes from Great Britain. It was a proposal of Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party just a few years ago. It goes like this: any business that wants to sell itself, close down, have an IPO, or move to another country must give its own employees something called the right of first refusal.
In other words, it has to say to the employees, “You have the first shot. If you can come up with the money, we will sell the enterprise to you.” That’s part A. Part B is that the British government (and this is what Corbyn pledged) would set up a special bank whose job would be to lend that money to the workers who make that choice.
That would very quickly create a worker co-op sector that everybody could access. And the last one (I have more, too, but this is the last one): the Federal Reserve System in this country regulates interest rates and the quantity of money in circulation. Those two variables affect every single person’s life, but there is no democratic involvement in what the Fed does.
Mr. Warsh, who’s the head of the Federal Reserve right now, has a personal wealth in the neighborhood of half a billion dollars. He’s the richest chair of the Federal Reserve we’ve ever had. It is a cozy group of people, half of whom are nominated by the president and half of whom are sitting there because they are leaders of the biggest private banks in the country.
Why in the world is something as important as the interest rate being decided by bankers, politicians, and the richest people in the country? The mortgages we pay, the car payments we make, the credit cards we use, the college student loans: they all depend on interest rates. That’s outrageous. There has to be a reorganization of the Federal Reserve that gives average people, unionized and non-unionized, access to seats on that board, so that the interests of the public can be genuinely expressed.
Richard Eskow: Let me go over those. Those are great ideas, and let me give a couple of reactions to them. On the maximum wage, first of all, I would assume that wouldn’t be just wage income; it would be all income. Maybe you were just thinking of a maximum wage, but you do get into the issue of unearned income: interest income, investment income, and all the other forms that are really driving inequality now.
So we’d have to think about that, but there’s no reason not to. Rent control? Yes, absolutely. I think it’s an enormously popular topic. What we always hear when people start talking about rent control is, “Oh, developers will leave. They’ll stop building new housing. You’ll have a housing shortage.”
Then you get into the YIMBY argument, the NIMBY argument, and the new neoliberal, young-Democrat “abundance” theology and all that. But to me, rent control ties very closely to the concept of public housing. First of all, public housing has a bad name in a lot of parts of this country because it’s been underfunded, whereas you’ve talked about Vienna and other places where public housing is great.
So first, adequately fund the public housing we have now, and kiss goodbye to developers as the engine of the housing stock by saying, “We will build the housing people need.” The Kerner Commission talked about this in 1968.
Richard Wolff: Right.
Richard Eskow: It said the government needs to pledge to create 6 million new housing units. Well, okay, let’s do that, so that rent control can be paired with it. To me, this also ties into the mythology (and I do think it’s a mythology) that if we just deregulate, so that in a place like Oakland you can build what they call “coffin apartments” in Hong Kong around the BART stations, then you’ll have a solution to the Bay Area’s housing problem and housing-cost problem.
No. Build houses. That’s how you get housing: you build it. You and I have been around long enough to see this stuff play out in real life. They build coffin apartments around the BART station, and they charge too much for them.
So we know that’s not the solution. The solution is decent housing for people. In terms of the wealth tax, absolutely. We have a federal income tax, so why couldn’t we have a federal wealth tax? The co-ops, absolutely. And on the Federal Reserve, you’re singing my song. During the last financial crisis, I was writing about how we need a “people’s Fed.” I’d love your thoughts on this, but I’ve felt for a long time that the Federal Reserve is absolutely archaic, not only in its dependence on the private banking system and its incestuous relationship with it.
I remember writing about JPMorgan Chase. In the same year that it paid something like $20 billion in fines in 2014, an astronomical number, its CEO was chair of the compensation committee of the Federal Reserve. So he was telling Ben Bernanke how much he was going to get paid.
So how does that work? But I also thought about the geographic structure: you have the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Chicago, and so on, as well as New York. When it was created, maybe it made sense to see the country as a set of interests aligned around geography like that.
But I think our interests are now aligned by class and by other factors. So why wouldn’t we have, for example, labor seats and professional seats? We could reimagine it any number of ways. Maybe both the structure and the people who take the seats could be publicly voted on.
So, a two-part question. First, why do we even need this geographic structure and some of the other superstructure we have now? And second, how does this tie into the federal government’s budgeting process? I’m not going to say the only thing of value I got from looking at Modern Monetary Theory was this, because that sounds negative.
But one thing it did get me thinking about was budgeting as a resource-allocation process, rather than budgeting as a question of where the money goes. You’re already accounting for inflation that way.
If you promise everybody a wooden ship, you run out of trees and wood gets expensive. Okay, I get that. But let’s start with the Federal Reserve. How would democratizing the Federal Reserve tie into, say, a federal budget process that is more focused on where people, things, and resources go and need to go (what we have and where we can put it), as opposed to abstractions like GDP numbers or deficits, which, to a lot of people, don’t affect their lives?
Big question, I know, and I apologize for it, but…
Richard Wolff: No, no. That’s a large part of what Modern Monetary Theory was designed to suggest. The government’s job is to do things like maintain employment and keep the economy functioning, yet we insert an institution called the Federal Reserve between the government and the economy.
Only if the Federal Reserve buys and sells the securities issued by the government do we have the flexibility to increase or decrease the money supply and raise or lower interest rates. That effectively gives those bankers a veto over the government’s monetary policy, which is why the Federal Reserve is there. And our critique is: who are they to have a veto?
Or, if there’s going to be a veto, why them? Why not put the veto in the hands of something much more obviously and democratically representative of a complex economy, instead of a group of bankers who are all highly paid, in a very rarefied job, with the very particular perspective that got them onto the Federal Reserve in the first place?
To give you an example of how it matters: when you have inflation, the government usually comes under pressure. From whom? From the mass of people who are suffering because prices are going up and their incomes are not rising to match. They want something done. So the government is told, “Do something.”
Well, what have governments under the Republicans and the Democrats done? They’ve turned the issue over to the Federal Reserve. And what has it done? It has raised or lowered interest rates. Now, that’s very interesting. If you have inflation, meaning rising prices, the Federal Reserve’s response has been to raise another price: the price of money, an interest rate.
Is that one way to try to deal with inflation? Yes, it is. Is it the only way? Not at all. Richard Nixon showed us another way.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Richard Wolff: In 1971: a wage-price freeze. That has been done in many countries at many times. The genius of the Federal Reserve was to make sure it was never discussed. It’s not that it wasn’t done. Over the last two decades, we acted as if what I just described never happened. People can look it up: August 15, 1971, was the day Richard Nixon did it.
We had a wage-price freeze. It is an amazing thing that this country, having seen how well a wage-price freeze worked, goes through an inflation and doesn’t even have a conversation about it. Janet Yellen, if I’m not mistaken, was sitting atop the Treasury Department at that time, and she simply ignored it. And I know personally (just between you and me) that she sat in the same class at Yale University, heard the same professor give us the same lecture, and took notes just as I did. We both know that the interest rate is not the only way to deal with this.
But in our country, those people up there at the Federal Reserve, utterly divorced from the general public, not representative, not participatory, living lives of great luxury, make the decision. It’s outrageous. It’s anti-democratic. It’s unfair. They only make matters worse. And on top of that, they often don’t succeed.
In other words, the inflation doesn’t come down.
Richard Eskow: And we’re a country whose political culture prides itself on its sense of individual freedom and rights. Yet this is a kind of totalitarian infringement, of the worst paternalistic sort, to say, “Eskow and Wolff, you’re buying too much food.”
Richard Wolff: Right.
Richard Eskow: “And it’s bad for business. So we’re going to make it harder for you to buy food, and you’ll buy less of it.” Who was it, the Republican candidate for Senate who, when a questioner said people can’t afford beef, said there are other proteins? She probably lost because of that this year. There’s always dog food, Richard and Richard.
Richard Wolff: Yeah.
Richard Eskow: So people are not connected to this democratic function, or to the healthcare system. That’s another example: rather than tweaking the mechanisms of subsidies that flow from the government to insurance companies, so that people can still overpay and not be adequately insured, let’s take the resource-allocation part of the earlier Modern Monetary Theory conversation. Why don’t we say, “Look, we’ve got a lot of this kind of doctor, and we don’t have enough of that kind of doctor”?
“We have too many hospitals in this town, and we don’t have enough in that town.” Why don’t we figure out what it would take to get some good doctors and a better hospital in that town? Do we really need three $250,000 MRI machines within half a mile of each other in Pittsburgh and none in half of the state of Nevada?
Why not plan it, again on a resource basis? “Well, we don’t have enough doctors to cover that.” Can’t we train more doctors? As it is, we don’t train enough, so we’re importing them from other places. And we make the entry barrier for young aspiring physicians too high in terms of test-taking skills, so they go to other countries, like Poland or Guatemala, and then they come back.
Why don’t we just train the doctors we need, hire them, pay them a decent wage, and get them where they need to go? And people will always be able to afford food, because we’re not going to be manipulating the interest rate. Assuming all that makes sense to you, let me bring it back to this: if we have any real (dare I say) comrades in the new House, do we think they could present something like this?
It would just say, “Look, Medicare for All is great, but we also want a rational planning system for healthcare in this country.” And, “Look, the Federal Reserve has got to go, or it has to be restructured. It’s an undemocratic mess.”
I think you’d be amazed how many right-wingers would sign on to that agenda. Workers ought to have the option of forming their own businesses with other workers. We have the mythology (well, it’s not a mythology, I guess it’s factually true) that Steve Jobs and Wozniak started Apple in a garage.
Now Apple is a monopolistic corporation. Why don’t we encourage some workers to become the new Apple and break up the monopolistic system that prevents that from happening? In other words, you and I have names for viewpoints like this, ideologies like this, but they’re names that make some people in this country nervous.
So we ought to be thinking about it this way: we could say, “Well, yeah, I think we call that a socialist economy,” or “I think we call that a planned economy,” or “I think we call it common sense,” right? I sometimes quote Earl Browder, the 20th-century leader of the Communist Party of the United States, and it’s dangerous. I was not an enthusiast of the man, but he had a good quote.
He said, “Communism is 20th-century Americanism.” Now, I’m not saying this is communist or anything else. I’m just asking: is there a way to pull all of this together so that it starts to cohere as a viewpoint, politically and in the public mind, that says, “Hey, there’s another way of going at all of this”?
Richard Wolff: Well, I feel very emboldened on this subject, if you like. After 75 years of relentless propaganda against everything on the left, the word “socialism” is nonetheless being used by people across the country in a way that seems to be okay. The population seems to have come through this, with a clear half or more of the people no longer blown away by the use of that term.
I will forever credit Bernie for being courageous enough, 10 years ago, to refuse to disassociate himself from that name and to say to the American people, “Go ahead, I can make it attractive to you.” And he did. And he has now shown it. For me, the single most important result was the decision of the people of Los Angeles to put a woman who calls herself a socialist in the mayor’s job.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Richard Wolff: I mean, what are we saying about a country whose two largest cities are governed by socialist mayors? Granted, it’s a moderate kind of socialism, but what would we expect in a country like this? Anyway, the even more important point is that I don’t think we have to worry about the name the way we used to.
And I think one of the ways to take that further is to do a little more work on American history. I find that when I talk about what Richard Nixon, a conservative Republican after all, did (he didn’t raise interest rates; he did a wage-price freeze), it becomes less of a strange, weird socialist idea and becomes something else.
At the end of World War II, Americans made the following decision. During the Great Depression, nobody had been building houses, because it was too expensive and there wasn’t a market for it. Then came the war, and construction had to be postponed because the resources had to be used for the war.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Richard Wolff: So 1945 comes, and you’ve basically had 16 years of inadequate housing construction. So we had an enormous program of building public housing, built by the government all over the United States. Now, it’s true that the business community, the private landlords and all of that, were horrified by all of this, and they engineered its destruction by making it housing for the poor, which is not what it initially was.
And then it became housing for racial minorities.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Richard Wolff: Then it was housing for poor racial minorities, and so you created the association that public housing is housing for poor Black people. It’s disgusting. It was bad for the poor people who were stuck in there, it was bad for Black people, and it was unfair and unjust. We can say that, and then say: imagine a program done the proper way, with enough refinement to make these attractive homes.
I think we can do that. And if you used economies of scale, doing it on a national basis, it could be much cheaper than having it done ad hoc by individual building companies.
Richard Eskow: And this is part of what I was driving at with the “20th-century Americanism” quote. We’ll wrap up in a minute, but it was precisely what you’re talking about, whether it’s Richard Nixon’s wage and price freeze, Dwight Eisenhower’s national highway system, the New Deal, or Ronald Reagan talking about employee-owned enterprises, even though he was doing that through stock vehicles and employee stock participation.
All these ideas have been seeded throughout American history for a long time. And I would close with this: we just celebrated Veterans Day. My mother’s family was military, and they always said that the military is the most socialistic institution in the United States of America, and the most popular institution according to public opinion polls, because people appreciate the idea of collective action and collective service.
And the Veterans Administration used to run the best medical system in the country, which was a public system. So maybe we could throw into our new basket of bold ideas a kind of national Veterans Administration healthcare system for everyone, right? Medicare for All is great, but why don’t we do it the way France does: build the hospitals and hire the doctors?
Something else to think about. But with that, I’ll give you the closing word.
Richard Wolff: Yeah, I liked the image of the military. In a number of other countries (France comes to mind), the military is given a whole set of multiple functions. In many parts of France, members of the military are required, as part of their service, to work in their communities’ fire departments, so there’s an overlap there.
And the gratitude people come to feel toward the firefighters who make sure there isn’t a fire in the community is not bad for the military. Then they’re not simply standing around in weird uniforms, making bad noises with their dangerous guns. They’re actually doing something socially useful, and they could do many other things that are socially useful.
It could be part of their military service, but it would now be a service in which public service came first and only a portion was military. You have that in a number of countries.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Richard Wolff: Various countries have played with that. Let me end this way. Around the world, in most countries, there never was quite the taboo against socialism that we’ve had for the last 75 years. And therefore, many of them (not all, but many) have been much more willing and able to experiment with the kinds of ideas you and I have just talked about.
In short, there is a repository of concrete experience that the United States could take advantage of, adjusted for our conditions. You don’t copy it, but you use it to start the process. We ought to have a government that is committed to doing that. Imagine an early stage of a new Democratic government, coming in and saying, “We’re going to set up a special commission whose job is to find out how other countries are solving their problems in ways we might learn from.”
They would have to report to Congress every three months and give it a menu of options. That would be made public, and there could be public debate about these things.
Richard Eskow: I think that would be great. And it could be even broader. It could be an institute of new political thinking.
Richard Wolff: Yeah.
Richard Eskow: It could look at new ideas and at ideas that are already being implemented elsewhere. I’m always saying that our social imaginations haven’t kept up with our technological imaginations. For our safety, our security, and the well-being of future generations, we’d better get on the case. So why not? Okay, we just came up with a good idea. The best idea yet, I would say, for our new Bloc members, our lefty Bloc members.
Richard Wolff: I think it would also be a good corrective, so that the new Democratic government coming in doesn’t look like its number-one priority is investigating and criminalizing the Republicans, doing back to them what they did to the Democrats, instead of dealing with the social problems.
Richard Eskow: Right. Well, I feel the same way, and I’ve already gotten into some arguments about that, but that’s for another time. Professor Richard Wolff, as always, it’s a great pleasure talking with you, and thanks for coming on the program.
Richard Wolff: My pleasure, too, and I look forward to our next one.
Richard Eskow: As do I. We depend on your support here at The Zero Hour, so please give whatever you can at any of the links you see on your screen. Thanks so much.
