I was joined once again by Alissa Quart, author and Executive Director of the Economic Hardship Reporting Project, and Lynn Parramore, author, cultural historian and senior researcher with the Institute for New Economic Thinking. Alissa and Lynn tackled the human pain of artificial technology once again in their latest piece, “Okay, Zoomer, You’re the First Human Surplus Generation” (The New Republic). “For Gen Zers,” they write, “job hunting can feel like a game rigged to waste their time, where the prize is a spectral illusion.”
Economic precarity is nothing new, especially for younger and lower-income people. But the insertion of AI, into both the job-seeking process and a person’s beliefs about their future, can be an especially soul-killing experience. As Lynn and Alissa write:
“The old promise of entry-level work, where you find a position, learn the ropes, and make your way up, was already fading. Gen Xers and millennials can tell you that. But AI is quickening the unraveling, disrupting how young people find jobs—if they find jobs—and also what they confront when they get there. Gen Z is squinting into a fog, unsure of what’s coming, yet certain that disembodied decision-makers will have a say in it.”
We covered a lot of ground in this conversation, including culture, consciousness, resistance, and more. But it all flowed together! It’s great when that happens (and it can’t be replicated by chatbots).
Please give it a listen. (Quotes and transcript below.)
Selected Quotes
“They’re starting to believe they’re people who might not be necessary for any labor whatsoever.”
—Lynn Parramore“When we wrote this we didn’t think, ‘Oh, this is the end of knowledge work.’ We thought, ‘This is the end of learning on the job.’”
—Alissa Quart“They’re being told ‘You’re superfluous... You’re a substrate, like a vein of coal.’”
—Richard Eskow
Related links:
—“Okay, Zoomer, You’re the First Human Surplus Generation”
—Economic Hardship Reporting Project
—For Workers, ‘AI’ Means ‘Apocalyptic Insecurity’ (w/Lynn Parramore, Alissa Quart)
This work is only possible thanks to continuing reader support. If you find it worthwhile, please help out with a paid subscription through Substack (discounted here) or on Patreon. You can also make a one-time contribution here.
Many thanks—RJE
Transcript (lightly edited)
Richard Eskow: Joining me once again are two writers I very much respect. Lynn Parramore is an author and cultural critic. Alissa Quart is an author, a journalist, and the editorial director of the Economic Hardship Reporting Project, which is an excellent group. If you don’t know them or their work, you should track it down and find out about it.
They have a new piece out in The New Republic, headlined (and I know we don’t always write our own headlines) “Okay, Zoomer, You’re the First Human Surplus Generation.” It’s a great piece, and it raises a lot of provocative points. So first of all, Lynn and Alissa, welcome back to The Zero Hour.
Lynn Parramore: Awesome to be with you.
Alissa Quart: Great to be with you. And we did write that headline.
Lynn Parramore: We did.
Richard Eskow: Oh, you did write that.
Lynn Parramore: It was all ours. Alissa came up with “Okay, Zoomer,” and I came up with “human surplus.”
Alissa Quart: Yeah.
Richard Eskow: The human surplus. Yes. For years now I’ve used the phrase “excess human inventory” to describe a certain worldview that predates AI, right?
Lynn Parramore: The idea goes back to Marx’s industrial reserve army. We all remember that. And his point is even scarier now, because it’s not just people being displaced in one industry and moving into another. It’s people who might not be necessary for any labor whatsoever.
Richard Eskow: Right. And Lynn and Alissa, the last time we talked, I think I mentioned John Ruskin, and you mentioned your interest in Ruskin and his line: you can either make a tool of the creature or a human being of him; you cannot do both. I think the real innovation of AI is that they’re saying we don’t need either.
You are absolutely superfluous. Our machines can operate themselves, so we don’t need you to turn the wheels and check the levers. And we certainly don’t want you to be a human being, because you’ll disrupt our lives. If anything, you’re raw material. You’re a substrate, like ore, like a vein of coal, but you are no longer an instrument or an entity in any way.
To me, that shows just how dehumanizing this is. And that’s one of the reasons I thought your piece was so important. It was saying (and correct me if you disagree with my interpretation) that the experience of graduating into this terraformed, increasingly mechanized economy is more dehumanizing than anything in modern memory.
Is that a fair statement?
Lynn Parramore: Absolutely. We use the term “anticipatory obsolescence” in the piece. That used to be a term we might apply to things like iPhones: you buy one, and the people who made it have made sure it won’t work properly in two or three or four years.
You’ll have to buy another one. Now human beings feel that way, and Generation Z in particular. When you internalize the message that you might not be needed in this economy, that your skills are obsolete before you’ve even graduated and gotten out the door, much less gained a foothold in the workforce, that is a deeply unsettling experience.
Richard Eskow: Yeah. One of the things in your piece that felt most like a gut punch to me (and Alissa, this tracks closely with the work of the Economic Hardship Reporting Project) was the description of applying for a job and dealing with this dehumanized, vacuous AI. Those of us who weren’t born into privilege, who had the misfortune of having to apply for jobs, sometimes in desperate financial straits, sometimes for entry-level positions, know it’s a terrible experience under the best of circumstances.
I just don’t know how anyone endures that, particularly someone new to this world, under 25 and still cognitively malleable. It struck me as awful. It struck me as a new level, or a new dimension, of worker degradation. Do you think that’s a fair statement?
Alissa Quart: Yeah. I talked to Ben. That’s the name he chose, because he didn’t want his real name used, even though he’s one of probably hundreds of thousands of young job seekers who are now being interviewed by AI. I was really struck by his description of sitting there trying to please an algorithmic entity.
As you just pointed out, this isn’t entirely new. We were always trying to please somebody in an alienated way. Try being interviewed in the middle of a recession in the ‘90s, and try being a young woman on top of that. Not fun. But at least it was a human being, someone you could potentially connect with, who might see themselves in you or see your value.
This interviewer is literally looking for certain words from the candidate, words that will pass them on to the next level. That means people like Ben are now learning those words through AI training. Then they go into interviews and say the things they think will please the AI. “Synergy,” I don’t know.
Just a kind of corporate balderdash. And he was a serious, interesting guy who works in some quadrant of the finance-tech industry. He started looking to mysticism after this experience, because he began to ask himself: What is my generation? What is my value? What is a job? And what is my future?
Richard Eskow: That’s so interesting. It reminds me of something I read and wanted to write about the other day. It was a study showing that only about 20 percent of people in majority Arab Muslim countries thought AI had any possibility of becoming conscious, while something like 80 percent of people in Western countries believed it did.
The person writing it up suggested that was probably because people in those Arab countries haven’t been exposed to AI, and that they have a religious faith that supersedes it. My response was no, you’re talking about two competing religious faiths. To me, the idea that AI is conscious is a theological statement.
There’s no evidence to back it up, right? So at the same time that these young people are having to deal with clearly nonhuman, plastic interactions, the people putting them through it are justifying it to themselves with the belief that they’re relating to another living being.
Does that make sense? Do you know what I’m trying to say?
Lynn Parramore: Absolutely. And the consciousness issue is such an interesting one. There’s a conversation in art, and since we’re all writers, there’s a conversation about writing. Could AI write a Booker Prize-winning novel? We’re already seeing these discussions, and people are using AI to write things that are well regarded and winning prizes. But what does it mean to read a book?
You are entering another human consciousness.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: That’s your expectation, and that’s how you derive meaning from it. It applies across so many discussions, too. I recently heard Tyler Cowen argue that we should have AI teaching college classes, and that AI can be so validating and engaging. But when I look back on my college experience, and the professors whose classes meant something to me, the engagement came from a human being with a human consciousness.
It was a human being I might want to emulate. It was a human being who valued me as another human being. I just don’t see how interacting with AI replaces those experiences. It’s not a consciousness.
Richard Eskow: That’s such an interesting question. And actually, I was going to bring up Tyler Cowen in this conversation, because one of his essential ideas, which Thomas Friedman glommed onto years ago, was that “average is over.” Cowen wrote very specifically about the implication: that roughly 85 percent of humanity would become superfluous.
In that sense, he was prophetic, right? I knew at the time, and I wrote at the time, that his work was adored inside Silicon Valley billionaire society. He wrote about the 85 percent, and about the 15 percent who were demonstrably above average and would thrive. That was his vision. It’s The Time Machine, the Eloi and the Morlocks, right?
So what do you do with the 85 percent? Keep them doped on religion and sex and TV, as John Lennon said, and throw in AI and social media and all that. And dope. So you have someone like that reflecting what seems to me to be the pathology behind this entire system. It’s a kind of solipsism; I don’t even know exactly how to describe it. A sense of alienation from one’s own soul, if I may use that word.
Look, people at Anthropic argue that Claude, its bot, has a soul. Well, if you really have a spirit, a personality, a psyche, I can’t believe you could write what Tyler Cowen wrote, the things you just quoted. And I can’t believe you could believe your bot has one too, particularly if you understand the technology and the science driving it.
As for the claim that it could write a Booker Prize novel: well, it could steal from a variety of sources and recombine them in ways that we don’t recognize, that the Booker judges don’t recognize, and win a Booker Prize. But it didn’t write it.
Lynn Parramore: And it didn’t live anything connected to the emotions being expressed. I don’t really want to know how an AI is going to recombine ideas about romance or sexuality or grief, or any of these human experiences. I want to know how a human being addresses those things.
Alissa Quart: You know what, Richard? Strangely, I feel like this makes an argument for reporters and memoirists. A lot of what the Economic Hardship Reporting Project, which I co-founded with Barbara Ehrenreich, supports are first-person essays by working-class people about their experiences. And you can’t really fake lived experience.
I mean, I guess you could. I guess you could have a bot write it. But part of the whole point of reading that kind of work is to read testimony, right? So maybe there’s going to be a turn toward that kind of work. Maybe I’m being self-serving here, but I mean the kind of work our organization puts out: work by people who are living these lives, the 85th percentile lives, and who really want to record them, recording the indignities but also the pleasures. And reporting is something you typically do on the phone or in person.
That’s a bodily thing, too, right? You need to be embodied. So maybe there’s going to be a nonfiction resurgence. Who knows?
Richard Eskow: Well, people can dream.
Lynn Parramore: It strikes me that this really tracks with an economic argument we’ve been making at the Institute for New Economic Thinking, where I work: the idea of a dual economy. A dual economy has been taking shape in the United States since the ‘70s.
It’s something we used to associate with developing countries. And that 85 percent figure roughly tracks how economists like Peter Temin have broken it down: about 20 percent in one economy (or 15 percent, if you will) and 80 percent in the other. We don’t have the same life experiences. We don’t have the same expectations.
We don’t have the same healthcare system. We don’t have the same transportation system. And I think AI is amplifying this bifurcation in a really concerning way. The other thing about what you said that concerns me is that people in Silicon Valley equate being in that top 20 or 15 percent, and having resources and money, with being good and wise and altruistic.
We hear that all the time out of Silicon Valley, along with the idea that they’re in the best position to make decisions about the future. That is particularly concerning. And I think in this recent election, you may have seen a reflection of the fact that Gen Z in particular isn’t buying all these narratives from Silicon Valley.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: They’re pushing back. They had record-breaking turnout, the highest in about three decades, I think. They were instrumental in flipping Texas, and so on. They’re just not buying what Silicon Valley is selling.
Richard Eskow: Right, I think that’s an important point. And I think it goes back to... well, I blame the trolley problem. I was a student when the trolley problem came out. Do you pull the switch...
Alissa Quart: Yeah, I love it.
Richard Eskow: ...and save six lives and kill two, or do you leave it alone and let the six die? They think it’s an arithmetic problem: six minus two, so you save four lives. No, it’s a problem of self. It’s a problem of identity. Once you pull the switch, you’re a murderer.
They’ve missed the entire point of what made it shocking when it came out, because our political and social culture has been dehumanized to the point that everything is quantitative, right? Nothing is qualitative anymore. And that’s what you’re talking about. Oddly enough, that’s what I’m going to use to pivot to the quantitative for a moment, because I do think it’s important to understand exactly what Gen Z is up against.
You cite a Census Bureau study showing that employment among 22- to 24-year-olds fell 12 percent in the most AI-exposed industries. Do you remember what some of those industries were, by the way? I’m blanking.
Lynn Parramore: Well, certainly computer science and computer engineering. But we’re also seeing a downward trend in hiring, particularly among Gen Z, in the service sector, which has been hit hard. And interestingly, there’s a gender split happening. Because computer science is male-dominated, you might think it would be mostly young men losing their jobs.
But if you look at the numbers, a recent report out of Stanford suggests that young women are getting hit even harder, at least in the last quarter, because of the pullback in service-industry jobs. So it’s hitting people in different ways in different industries. But at this point, you’d be hard-pressed to name an industry in which people’s jobs are not being affected by AI.
Even plumbing. Any job you can think of.
Alissa Quart: Journalism. I constantly hear from people who come to EHRP, or just people in my life, who were copy editors or writers. Often they weren’t just writers; they were doing brand writing. These aren’t jobs you’d necessarily think of first, but that work is now being generated entirely by AI. Or there are reports for clients and businesses that used to employ researchers, or even anthropologists, and now those are being created by AI too.
That’s why economic concerns are top of mind for 18- to 29-year-olds now. And it’s part of why Gen Z candidates, the Democratic candidates, are getting so much love from Gen Z voters. There was an enthusiasm gap, which I liked, between how Gen Z felt about the Democrats and the Republicans. They were much more into the Democratic candidates.
I think they’re starting to think that AI shouldn’t just be a subject for online complaints, WhatsApp complaints, or complaints on campus. It needs to be a bigger movement.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Alissa Quart: That’s part of what we document in the piece. We talked to people from PauseAI US, who have been lobbying for moratoriums. They call them pauses, because they’re not full moratoria. And then there are the people we call the AI refuseniks, who are just refusing it altogether. They’re using dumb phones.
They’re trying to limit their internet use entirely, and they’re trying to create an alternative universe, a kind of Luddite universe, where they don’t participate. So there are different strands, and we found they’re all related to how some of these Gen Zers are responding to this job loss and this existential threat.
Richard Eskow: Yeah, and I couldn’t be more sympathetic. I think one of the phrases that came up among the refuseniks was “the Summer of Ludd.”
Alissa Quart: Yes, yeah.
Richard Eskow: I love that.
Alissa Quart: Me too. They’re amazing. I hung out with them, and they also have this kind of Merry Prankster energy. The only problem with them, as far as I could tell, is that some of them are relatively privileged. It’s hard to be working class and not have a phone, right?
Richard Eskow: Right.
Alissa Quart: But they are super smart and diverse, and they have a great sense of fun. They have “delete days,” where they gather people together to delete apps and the other subscriptions that wind up on their phones. They have “let’s get offline” dance parties where they mock Sam Bankman-Fried or whoever.
Richard Eskow: I love it.
Alissa Quart: With costumes. They have a real sense of joy. It reminded me a little of something I wrote about a lot in my first book, Branded: the 1990s Adbusters and anti-WTO activism, where people wore costumes and there was a lot of fun.
Richard Eskow: Culture jamming.
Alissa Quart: Culture jamming. Exactly.
Richard Eskow: I have a suggestion for them, which is that they go online for an hour a day and just write absolute nonsense to pollute AI output with misinformation and grammatical rules that don’t exist in real life. Just digital sabotage. I’d be all for it, and I don’t think it would be illegal, by the way.
But I love that spirit. It has to be a spirit of fun, and God knows their lives aren’t especially fun right now. You also describe the different groups. You’ve got the refuseniks, for whom, in my heart, I probably have the most affection. Then you have the reformers, who are critically important: regulation, labor protections, and transparency, I guess.
And then you have the adapters, which I would guess is the largest group, right?
Lynn Parramore: Sure. Out of necessity, if nothing else.
Richard Eskow: Sure.
Lynn Parramore: If you’re entering the workforce... and actually, there are colleges right now that are beginning to embed AI into the coursework, so being a refuser becomes very difficult under those circumstances. But we did find that a lot of young people are trying to create boundaries. They’re trying to keep AI out of some parts of their lives.
Their personal lives, let’s say. There’s a real sense of distrust and unease about things like AI companions, although everybody seems to know somebody who has used one. So they’re not adapters because they’re gung-ho enthusiasts. I was really surprised. I even talked to some young tech-bro types down in Silicon Valley.
Even they expressed a deep distrust of letting AI into the intimate parts of their lives. We talk about mentorship in the piece. There was a young man I interviewed who works as a computer engineer for a Silicon Valley company, and he talked about how mentorship is being affected because he can just ask AI a question and get an answer.
Richard Eskow: Mm-hmm.
Lynn Parramore: And that’s faster and easier than going to a colleague. Alissa and I discussed this, and she rightly pointed out that mentorship hasn’t been easy to come by for a lot of people, women, for example.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: But mentorship is how one human being shares their world with another, shares their consciousness with another. It teaches you things like the etiquette of a business meeting. Someone takes you out to lunch and you have a couple of drinks. It’s a kind of interaction you’re not going to get from an AI agent.
And relationships develop that really matter for the next steps in your career. So even the young people most deeply embedded in Silicon Valley are still concerned, and they are not wholehearted adapters at all.
Richard Eskow: A personal reflection there. I was a data guy back when I felt I had to work in the real economy. This was some time ago, and I did like part of it. I designed computer systems and so on (whoops, sorry about that), but I also did large-scale data analysis.
I remember going to work for a corporation where I was doing these huge data analyses: which subcontractor was more effective at this, which was more effective at that, analyzing the data in all these different ways. I was young, and I had a boss who just schmoozed all day.
All he did was put his feet up on the desk, talk to people on the phone, and get taken to basketball games and dinners. And I thought, what an idiot. I’m the future; he’s the past. But what I discovered was that he was a more reliable predictor than I was of who would be a trustworthy and effective partner in a business venture, because the human factors he picked up from getting to know these people contained elements I couldn’t parse from the data.
That was many years ago, so it has to be the same now, except that now it’s a very personal problem. (By the way, I didn’t mind getting taken to the occasional basketball game.) But now it’s a matter of people at their most vulnerable, right? Alissa, you...
Alissa Quart: Yeah.
Richard Eskow: I know there are many points of vulnerability in a working person’s life, including being laid off in midcareer. But isn’t the start of your career, in a way, when you’re most at risk? You haven’t developed the armor to protect yourself, and these young people are being brutalized.
Alissa Quart: Yeah, I think so. And you’re also not learning. One crucial thing that happens on the job is that while you’re earning a paycheck (in my case, I was being paid by the word), you’re improving, right? I was working with editors.
I was working with fact-checkers. I was a fact-checker. I learned the business that way. But what happens when all the roles that are instrumental to forming a profession are taken over by bots? It’s not just that it’s dispiriting to be human in a world of AI. It’s also that many of the things you would do, and practice, and get better at, are no longer there. They’re no longer part of the way up.
And the Silicon Valley people can say anything. They can say, “Oh, that’s great, because those were bullshit jobs.” They can co-opt Graeber that way: “This was just empty work.” But some of those tasks are how we come to understand, materially, what’s inside a profession, a body of knowledge, or an expertise.
It’s epistemological, honestly. That’s something we heard in this piece, and in the earlier piece we came on the show to discuss, where people told us, “The last 10 percent of a project is something that only I know, from having learned it.
“AI is not going to know it. So if I’m not there doing that last 10 percent, it’s just not going to get done, or errors will creep in.” That was an architect talking. And I think that’s probably what we’re seeing. Then we’re seeing young people who are just kind of rudderless.
I always talk about people losing the narrative of their lives, and that’s part of this, right? What are you hoping for? What do you want to be? We heard that from these sources. Because of the work I’ve been doing in this area, I now get letters from young people who say, “I just feel nihilistic about my generation and its possibilities.”
Richard Eskow: Yeah.
Alissa Quart: Gen X, or your generation, Richard, might have been afraid of nuclear war, or of Iran-Contra or Kent State or what have you. But we didn’t think, “This is the end of knowledge work. This is the end of learning on the job.” These are...
Lynn Parramore: Or perhaps the end of humanity.
Alissa Quart: Yeah, yeah.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: We’re actually talking about a product that might be helpful in some ways, but might also lead to human extinction.
Richard Eskow: Right. And it doesn’t have to be conscious to cause massive damage, by the way. Viruses aren’t conscious, but they sure as hell hurt. We only have a couple of minutes left, but before we go: Lynn, you mentioned the recent election. In your piece, if my notes are correct, 66 percent of young Democrats and 59 percent of young Republicans, roughly two-thirds of each, see AI as a threat to their job prospects.
Lynn Parramore: Right.
Richard Eskow: Then you have the whole anti-data center movement being driven by communities. I agree with you that this energy had a lot to do with the Democrats’ blue tsunami. But we also know there’s a lot of big tech money.
Lynn Parramore: Yes, there is.
Richard Eskow: So I guess the question, in the broadest sense, is how much room for optimism do we think there is?
Lynn Parramore: Or what kind of optimism are we talking about? I was watching James Talarico’s case very closely. He benefited a great deal from his relationship with Reid Hoffman, the LinkedIn co-founder and billionaire. And it’s interesting, because if you pay attention, his rhetoric around AI sounds a lot like Reid Hoffman’s.
Reid Hoffman is not someone who is interested in pausing AI.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: He is, by his own definition, a techno-optimist. He doesn’t talk in the crazy “move fast and break things” way that someone like Elon Musk might, but he’s probably not going to be interested in some of the reforms the young people we spoke to were really passionate about. So what representatives actually do, versus what Gen Z voters or the general public want them to do, is going to be a real question.
We know there are corporate Democrats like Hakeem Jeffries, and we pretty much know their playbook. I think it’s going to look very similar to how they dealt with the banking industry, which brought us the financial crisis.
Richard Eskow: Right.
Lynn Parramore: Then you have people who are going to be really tough on AI, people like AOC and Elizabeth Warren. We have a new Gen Z woman from Colorado in the House who is taking a tough stance on AI. But then you have these wiggly people in the middle, like Talarico, and we don’t know what they’re going to do yet. I would even put Sherrod Brown in that category.
He’s taken some money from Google. Not a huge amount, but still. I think we have to watch them very closely and see how well their actions and their rhetoric end up matching. And just because you have reform doesn’t mean you’ve changed the power structure, right? We had Dodd-Frank, which sounded really great, but did it really change the concentration of power in the banking industry?
Did it end “too big to fail”? No, it didn’t. So I would pay very close attention to that history right now, as these discussions about regulating Silicon Valley unfold.
Richard Eskow: Sounds like good fodder for activism. And Alissa, any last words?
Alissa Quart: I’m thinking we need a word for fake anti-AI discourse. “Artificial invective,” maybe. I don’t know. Maybe that’s our next piece, because it’s sort of a new astroturfing, I think.
Richard Eskow: Right, right. Yeah.
Alissa Quart: Yeah, totally. And I saw that when I reported for The Nation in Loudoun County, Virginia, which has the highest concentration of data centers. There are 233 of them in this suburb of Washington, D.C., across what, three suburbs? A lot of the people who were organizing were what I call accidental activists.
They were NIMBYs, and they weren’t Gen Zers, but they were really passionate. So I wonder what will happen if their passion isn’t answered by actual pauses, or if they just get some kind of faux moratorium. But one thing I find interesting is that a lot of the newly elected officials have had real jobs and have lived off their incomes.
They’re not dynasties. I’m thinking of the pediatrician Andrews, and Sam Forstag, the wildland firefighter in Montana. If we come back to work, I do think these are people who trained and who understand the value of work, of working in person, with bodies. That might be an advantage.
It could be. So that’s something I hope people lean into when they communicate with their elected officials: “You had a job. I want one too. I want to have expertise.”
Richard Eskow: Right. And I would say activism, ongoing activism, is a huge piece of it. For all of this, we’re going to need continued excellent reporting, writing, and analysis like your piece in The New Republic, Lynn Parramore and Alissa Quart: “Okay, Zoomer, You’re the First Human Surplus Generation.” Again, Lynn is a writer and cultural critic.
Alissa is the editorial director of the Economic Hardship Reporting Project. Thanks for your great work on this, and as always, thanks for coming on the program.
Lynn Parramore: Thank you. And we need you, Richard.
Alissa Quart: Bye, Richard. Thank you.
Richard Eskow: Thank you. Bye-bye.
Lynn Parramore: Thanks so much.
Richard Eskow: We depend on your support here at The Zero Hour, so please give whatever you can at any of the links you see on your screen. Thanks so much.

Outstanding discussion. If our species is going to have a future, we are all going to have to double down on our engagement and opposition to the AI takeover that’s currently underway.
As for faux anti-AI, it must be called out whenever encountered, as a faux in sheep’s clothing.
From my last day in Namibia.